|
On February 06 2015 01:55 Eden1892 wrote:
Just on a quick glance:
- Why did LightningStrike flip onto JAT from SL when SL was voting JAT?
- What's Koshi even doing? Maybe that's where I should be looking for people who I think aren't putting in time.
- If I think JAT is town then rsoultin and especially Damdred are probably town as well. I don't see why Damdred would be anywhere close to invested in the arguments around JAT if he were mafia. And rsoultin saying, in effect, "I see where you're going on JAT but I'm staying on SL" is pretty good if you assume JAT is town. It's not that she couldn't do that as mafia, but in any world where SL is mafia, she doesn't stay as mafia, she switches, imo. If SL is also town it's another story and she could be mafia.
- Oddly enough I still like SL. Sorry Damdred. I swear I'm not saying this just to piss you off.
- Holyflare, batsnacks and Onegu are all off doing their own thing. One of them is probably mafia.
- Don't remember why Breshke moved.
I think I like lynching Koshi and one of HF/batsnacks/Onegu, more likely HF/batsnacks because Onegu is already on Koshi.
Why is damdred town for siding with me? That is the easiest fucking thing in the world to do as scum. I am never getting mislynched and people will sooner rather than later realize that I am town and then he looks good. And even if you lynched me he would still look good.
|
On February 06 2015 01:58 marvellosity wrote:
i'm not lynching bats today.
Good boy.
|
O_o bresh said the case on sl was good. And then moved onto jat with SL....I already said that once but its really icky
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
and yes, let's introduce koshi into the mix.
now, bbl for realsies.
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
and yeah, mafia get way over-invested in defending townies all the time, it's a very natural thing to do
|
Eden i think you're in too many places. Maybe focus on one thing till you finish and then move to the next sequentially.
|
Yeah its a realy horrible reason to town read me on XD. I totally hard defended 2-3 townies in imperial for cred.
|
On February 06 2015 01:58 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2015 01:55 Eden1892 wrote:
Just on a quick glance:
- Why did LightningStrike flip onto JAT from SL when SL was voting JAT?
- What's Koshi even doing? Maybe that's where I should be looking for people who I think aren't putting in time.
- If I think JAT is town then rsoultin and especially Damdred are probably town as well. I don't see why Damdred would be anywhere close to invested in the arguments around JAT if he were mafia. And rsoultin saying, in effect, "I see where you're going on JAT but I'm staying on SL" is pretty good if you assume JAT is town. It's not that she couldn't do that as mafia, but in any world where SL is mafia, she doesn't stay as mafia, she switches, imo. If SL is also town it's another story and she could be mafia.
- Oddly enough I still like SL. Sorry Damdred. I swear I'm not saying this just to piss you off.
- Holyflare, batsnacks and Onegu are all off doing their own thing. One of them is probably mafia.
- Don't remember why Breshke moved.
I think I like lynching Koshi and one of HF/batsnacks/Onegu, more likely HF/batsnacks because Onegu is already on Koshi. Why is damdred town for siding with me? That is the easiest fucking thing in the world to do as scum. I am never getting mislynched and people will sooner rather than later realize that I am town and then he looks good. And even if you lynched me he would still look good.
It isn't him siding with you, it's that he bothered to be involved at all. He went back and dug out quotes showing where you pushed your read on him that I missed in my reading. He's been arguing the case with me since before you even arrived back in the thread. It's not impossible for him to do as mafia, but I can't see why he would give a shit, I guess? Seems like if he's mafia he would be more than happy to let me keep yelling about lynching you, especially when Palmar and marv were in the thread saying they'd want to lynch Damdred if not you.
|
On February 06 2015 02:00 marvellosity wrote:
and yeah, mafia get way over-invested in defending townies all the time, it's a very natural thing to do
Yeah, but when they're the alternate candidate? Because you and Palmar were very clearly going to lynch Damdred if not JAT
|
Also what am I missing about Breshke? I read his filter and it doesn't look passive like bats said.
|
On February 06 2015 02:03 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2015 02:00 marvellosity wrote:
and yeah, mafia get way over-invested in defending townies all the time, it's a very natural thing to do Yeah, but when they're the alternate candidate? Because you and Palmar were very clearly going to lynch Damdred if not JAT
This is a better point but a bit wifom.
Anyway, the main meh thing about bresh is the way he voted
|
Also eden why did you have such a hard on for jat following thread sentiment to you but youd on't see anything wrong with breshke filter when he sheeped onto jat with one of his scum reads because that's what was being talked about?
|
Eden I thought you were 100% sure I was town 
|
On February 06 2015 01:46 Eden1892 wrote:
Ugh fuck this stupid game I have to rethink AGAIN
... Hes done nothing but argue useless points.
|
On February 06 2015 02:02 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2015 01:58 justanothertownie wrote:On February 06 2015 01:55 Eden1892 wrote:
Just on a quick glance:
- Why did LightningStrike flip onto JAT from SL when SL was voting JAT?
- What's Koshi even doing? Maybe that's where I should be looking for people who I think aren't putting in time.
- If I think JAT is town then rsoultin and especially Damdred are probably town as well. I don't see why Damdred would be anywhere close to invested in the arguments around JAT if he were mafia. And rsoultin saying, in effect, "I see where you're going on JAT but I'm staying on SL" is pretty good if you assume JAT is town. It's not that she couldn't do that as mafia, but in any world where SL is mafia, she doesn't stay as mafia, she switches, imo. If SL is also town it's another story and she could be mafia.
- Oddly enough I still like SL. Sorry Damdred. I swear I'm not saying this just to piss you off.
- Holyflare, batsnacks and Onegu are all off doing their own thing. One of them is probably mafia.
- Don't remember why Breshke moved.
I think I like lynching Koshi and one of HF/batsnacks/Onegu, more likely HF/batsnacks because Onegu is already on Koshi. Why is damdred town for siding with me? That is the easiest fucking thing in the world to do as scum. I am never getting mislynched and people will sooner rather than later realize that I am town and then he looks good. And even if you lynched me he would still look good. It isn't him siding with you, it's that he bothered to be involved at all. He went back and dug out quotes showing where you pushed your read on him that I missed in my reading. He's been arguing the case with me since before you even arrived back in the thread. It's not impossible for him to do as mafia, but I can't see why he would give a shit, I guess? Seems like if he's mafia he would be more than happy to let me keep yelling about lynching you, especially when Palmar and marv were in the thread saying they'd want to lynch Damdred if not you.
I disagree. If Damdred is scum he KNOWS that I will not be lynched. He can push my wagon despite leaning town on me earlier and look extremely awful or he can keep defending me and not look awful. It is that easy.
|
Okay JAT isn't good to lynch today and I back at square 1 except it's possible Breshke and sicklucker would be mafia but I don't have a case on them.
|
On February 06 2015 02:11 Damdred wrote:
Also eden why did you have such a hard on for jat following thread sentiment to you but youd on't see anything wrong with breshke filter when he sheeped onto jat with one of his scum reads because that's what was being talked about?
I meant with the "passive" descriptor specifically, sorry. I see where you're coming from on his vote switch.
I think the passive part matters because it's the reason batsnacks keeps pushing on Breshke, and I'm not really sold on batsnacks being town. It'd help me get a read on bats if I knew where he's coming from.
I could lynch Breshke today, I think I rather Koshi because I expect more from him though. This guy rants way too much in obs qt about town not seeing obvious mafia for him to roll town and be this apathetic about the game.
|
I made a case on SL Ls what are you talking about? ITs still a good case to
|
On February 06 2015 02:18 LightningStrike wrote:
Okay JAT isn't good to lynch today and I back at square 1 except it's possible Breshke and sicklucker would be mafia but I don't have a case on them.
You don't have a case on sicklucker?
|
I'm liking my sheep more and more. People should sheep my sheep!
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
