Newbie Mini Mafia LIV - Page 23
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
| ||
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
On March 28 2014 03:06 Eden1892 wrote: Additionally, do I have this right as far as your reads go to this point? scum: Cavalinho, Pixalated maybe scum: Lord Tolkien town: all else I know OnceKing might be off-base; you were fine with me moving him to your town pile in my questions but that might have been for sake of discussion. I think the rest is correct based off of reading your filter. Yeah...I'm on the fence leaning scummy with OK. There have been +s for him, moreso of late, but there were a lot of minuses as well. | ||
RolandJarvis
65 Posts
On March 27 2014 04:46 Valenius wrote: I'll get onto Eden/Roland in a bit, but posting this for now. Quick totem pole. top doesn't mean i think he's confirmed scum, just highest on my list as it stands. Sqrt Cavalinho Pixelated Lord Tolkien OnceKing Robik Idk where roland / eden fit into that yet. By the time Valenius wrote this everybody had cleared eden. I think if he was scum making up reads he'd just join the party calling eden town. But if he's town and hasn't done the iso yet he can't. I'm not feeling a Valenius vote today. | ||
Eden1892
United States5866 Posts
On March 28 2014 03:07 IAmRobik wrote: meh....i'll concede that cava is more likely to be scum, but something is throwing me off about the way pixalated is playing the game and he is portraying a lot of scum tells. The whole situation with pixalated and LT makes me really really uneasy. I think Cavalinho's flip would tell us a lot about Pixalated and would help us figure out what's going on between Pixalated and Tolkien. Assuming you maintain that Cavalinho is more likely to be scum than Pixalated, then I believe the optimal move from your perspective is to get Cavalinho lynched. Do you follow me and if you do nonetheless disagree, what am I overlooking? | ||
OnceKing
United States939 Posts
On March 28 2014 03:11 RolandJarvis wrote: By the time Valenius wrote this everybody had cleared eden. I think if he was scum making up reads he'd just join the party calling eden town. But if he's town and hasn't done the iso yet he can't. I'm not feeling a Valenius vote today. Actually I disagree. The list is basically a fancy way to avoid saying what he thinks of Eden and you. Not to mention that he said he'd get back to Eden and he didn't. | ||
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
Also, I hate how quiet the thread got all of a sudden. What happened? | ||
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
On March 28 2014 03:31 OnceKing wrote: Actually I disagree. The list is basically a fancy way to avoid saying what he thinks of Eden and you. Not to mention that he said he'd get back to Eden and he didn't. Where the fuck did you come from? | ||
Eden1892
United States5866 Posts
I'm about ready to move back onto Cavalinho. I still don't like Tolkien at all here, but Jarvis made a really good point here about Cavalinho -- all of his posts throughout the day have been focused just on surviving the day. He doesn't actually look concerned about finding mafia. Even well after I moved off of him, he just seemed insistent on harping on my alleged "tunnel vision" with him (which doesn't even make sense given that I wasn't voting for him). And enough people (read: just about everyone) have assured me that Tolkien is just being a bad townie instead of actually mafia, with particular emphasis on him being bad at Day 1. I suppose given this I should give him the opportunity to demonstrate why I shouldn't kill him on Day 2. ##UNVOTE Lord Tolkien ##VOTE Cavalinho | ||
Valenius
United Kingdom1266 Posts
On March 28 2014 03:42 Eden1892 wrote: Gotcha. I'm about ready to move back onto Cavalinho. I still don't like Tolkien at all here, but Jarvis made a really good point here about Cavalinho -- all of his posts throughout the day have been focused just on surviving the day. He doesn't actually look concerned about finding mafia. Even well after I moved off of him, he just seemed insistent on harping on my alleged "tunnel vision" with him (which doesn't even make sense given that I wasn't voting for him). And enough people (read: just about everyone) have assured me that Tolkien is just being a bad townie instead of actually mafia, with particular emphasis on him being bad at Day 1. I suppose given this I should give him the opportunity to demonstrate why I shouldn't kill him on Day 2. ##UNVOTE Lord Tolkien ##VOTE Cavalinho If you're leaning towards LT being bad townie (even through taking others reads into account), does that then move your read on me anywhere? From the quick scan through, most of your scum feeling on me seems to come from interaction with LT (mostly me 'defending' his wtf-attempted-scum-bait-thing). Obviously correct me if i'm wrong, that isn't based on a line-by-line analysis of your posts. OnceKing: I'm going to address you in a bit, you've made a couple of posts that i really just don't understand. Food first. I hope it's nicer weather in our town, because it's pissing it down here. | ||
Eden1892
United States5866 Posts
I'd really rather focus on either killing Cavalinho or deciding who else to kill instead. | ||
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
I still dont like sqrt. More than Cav and am keeping the vote here. The only other thing i can do is consolidate on Cavwho is also is scummy but less so. And already set for lynch. This Val wagon and pixalated wagon needs to be at unhitched now. Do it tom o rrow or at night. If you think im more scummy than Cav Ok, fking vote for me. Not going to stop you. This is turning into a repeat of LII mafia. Reread your tunneling posts Eden. youtube video, memes now pansy ass beta bitch. Thos is mafia but fking chill and tone it down. Im fne with heat but the insults are getting annoying Phone outta batteries, so likely my last post. | ||
Valenius
United Kingdom1266 Posts
How in gods name can you think: + Show Spoiler + On March 27 2014 01:44 sqrtofneg1 wrote: Okay, going down the filter list. OnceKing brings up policy. I kind of disagree with bringing it up so early, but I think it was a town mindset that he did it. I read town. Eden is clearly town. Val hasn't been doing much, other than questioning the lurker policy, (kind of like me) so no read on him. LT clears Val in this post: Even though he hasn't done anything. Why would he do that? But wait, there's more. His next post is this: He demotes Val to leaning town. Maybe he now realizes that he was too obvious in pushing Val for town. If he's mafia, Val's also mafia. He also makes a scumtrap that's horribly planned out. Top mafia in my eyes. Robik's playing aggressive, as he normally does. He's been pressuring pretty much everybody, as a town should do. The one thing that I don't like is that he got a town read on my on joke posts before the game. that's strange. I read town. Pixalated is probably town. He's trying to logically put together the picture, and he's a bit quiet. He's suspicious of the right guys, he's cleared the right guys. I say town, with blue role. The blue role is because he's quiet. Cav seems mafia, with the same reasons as Robik and Eden. RJ is town, good reads, good logic. So it's either Cav + someone who I misread, or LT and Val. In that post he makes.. possibly one thought-out read? 'xxx is town' provides fuck all for anyone else to go on. He even calls pixalated out as probably being a blue role. Anyone, please chime in on this: How is that a good move? His LT read was based off of him not understanding anything of what went on. He's voted Cavalinho because he said he was going to post after work. He asked why only he should remove his vote on Cav, when asked to remove it. "Also, could you unvote me already? We've already determined that your vote was derp and I think you need to reread the thread to find a real scumread." "Also, I disagree with Robik's case against Pix." Give some reasons, how does that help anyone? He brushes off RJ when RJ asks for reasons why sqrt is town, and then in his very next post asks robik to do exactly the same for him. Maybe i just don't understand wtf sqrt is doing, he's the most unhelpful player in the thread. Anyway, back on to you OK, got a bit sidetracked there. "He cites his reason for suspicion as a lack of contribution but in fact Sqrt's post is very concise and clear, providing a huge amount of information about his motivations." in relation to sqrt's read post. I just can't wrap my head around how his post was informative. Maybe i'm being dumb, i just can't see it. | ||
Valenius
United Kingdom1266 Posts
| ||
OnceKing
United States939 Posts
Also, I may have been unclear. The post of sqrt's that I think is very clear and concise is this one: On March 27 2014 03:20 sqrtofneg1 wrote: Comes in, makes reads, avoids question. ##Unvote ##Vote: Cavalinho For some reason you had an issue with this post and used it to imply sqrt to be scummy when I think this post is very townie. | ||
Valenius
United Kingdom1266 Posts
Your cases last game were reasonably thought out, and i thought you'd gone insane with that case (my interpretation of your case). | ||
Valenius
United Kingdom1266 Posts
| ||
Eden1892
United States5866 Posts
On March 28 2014 04:32 Lord Tolkien wrote: Reread your tunneling posts Eden. youtube video, memes now pansy ass beta bitch. Thos is mafia but fking chill and tone it down. Im fne with heat but the insults are getting annoying Mocking terrible posts that attempt and fail, spectacularly, at responding to my points isn't tunneling. And I called you that to get you to say outright whatever the hell you're trying to imply with that comment about me "toeing the line of acceptable play." Like I said before, man up and say what it is you're meaning. I got no patience for cowards, alignment aside, and sniping with insinuations instead of straight shooting is cowardly. | ||
Balla24
2322 Posts
sqrtofneg1 (2) - OnceKing (0) - IAmRobik (0) - Cavalinho (3) - Eden1892 (0) - Lord Tolkien (1) - Valenius (2) - OnceKing, Pixalated Pixalated (1) - IAmRobik Not Voting (0) - Currently Cavalinho is set to be lynched! Day ends at Thursday, Mar 27 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00), . | ||
IAmRobik
United States5878 Posts
##vote LT | ||
Eden1892
United States5866 Posts
Cavalinho because he hasn't been scumhunting all game and because he never really addressed the case I built against him back earlier in the day. Case is obvious and has been elaborated on at length, no worries here. Robik because he came in and knocked the Cavalinho lynch off-course, and I later got him to admit Cavalinho was scummier than his target Pixalated (which was a weak target to settle on anyway), but now he's voting for Tolkien who he has as less scummy than Cavalinho. Their interaction at the beginning that I harassed Cavalinho over makes more sense now that I have Robik as the other scum; they were both fishing for an easy case against OnceKing and Cavalinho just followed Robik's lead. I've also been getting a really weird feeling about how Robik comes in acting like this badass at mafia, but whenever he talks to me he's just a monstrous pussy afraid to challenge me. Only makes sense if he's mafia and knows he can't afford to fuck with me. If Cavalinho flips scum then kill Robik tomorrow for sure. If he doesn't then I'll reassess but I'm really confident now in both of them being the scumteam. | ||
| ||