I'm switching my vote back to gumshoe.
Koshi here are my brief thoughts on Shape.
I have not played with mafia Shape and in the town games I recall (nutcracker, which I've hosted, newbie 18) he has never stuck out to me as overly townie. His volume to content ratio had always been high. His AFKness this game is obviously NAI. There were two posts in his filter (I mentioned it before, honestly can't remember the numbers now) that showed some sort of townie thinking, but the thing I'm trying to take into context is that if someone isn't around to play they also aren't going to make the greatest mover/shaker/impact reads you are seeking.
This doesn't make him town but I want to get the info I can in mylo on him, which is why I'm presently frustrated at his play.
The other thing that I want to also re-review - and that I also draw attention to - is gumshoe's case on GB at the time it happened. I know there were several points he made that were identical to my concerns. I saw the points he made were drawn out at a stretch with GB which after the time stamp error I concluded were town on town. But a key caveat now that I see in the manner he's pushing me are the points where he's reframing the arguments to make me look mafia.
There was a long bullet point list he drew on GB and there were some bullet points on the list that also looked meh or not necessarily indicative of mafia. I dismissed it at the time, focusing on the points that were similar to mine.
Seeing what he's doing with me this cycle, reviewing his pushes on GB and comparing those to his play this cycle will should give the remaining town here a better idea whether that was confirmation bias or malicious.
Going to try and get that on my next break.