|
On February 15 2016 06:48 keanuisgod wrote: That was a question (I phrased wrongly):
"Robik and NNN, do you think there is anything at all from Valdi that could actually indicate inactive townie instead of scum?" Well I still don't understand why you townread the guy all game, and why you are undecided now.
|
I thought he replaced at the middle of D1 ?
|
On February 15 2016 06:53 keanuisgod wrote: Dude's been inactive since the middle of D1, and a lot of interesting shit has happened since. He was there both days of D1 at approximativaly the same though. He just AFKd his vote on a lurker town and GTFO. Actually that is even more scum indicative. The dude was AFK since 3/4 of D1 to 1/2 of D2, so for like 50 hours. Townie are more likely to explain why they are AFK than scum. That seems stupid but it's the case. p:
|
On February 15 2016 07:11 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2016 06:48 Iwasrobik wrote:On February 15 2016 06:18 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: Also we need consolidation. If robik is scum, he can and will last minute switch onto another wagon. No way my partner would be the person I agressively push as soon as I enter the thread. Although this is meta so I can't prove it. You aggressively pushed Keanu not really valdi I voted Vlad and changed my mind on Kaenu it's not really invalid either.
|
On February 15 2016 07:20 Wartrukk wrote: Hm, should I switch so scum can't last minute hammer or what? Probably So you're sure Vlad is scum to think about the scenario where scum woiuld switch off him right ?
|
I think both are scum. I'm more sure on Vald though. And nobody can switch off him 'cause we just lynch him tomorrow, since we're at MYLO not LYLO.
|
On February 15 2016 07:53 Wartrukk wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2016 07:51 keanuisgod wrote: What do you think Valdi will flip right now?
Tell us ALL your thoughts about Valdi, before he flips and this will be invalid Off the top of my head 'he posted a few times day 1 and I liked the posts at the time' I'll have a gander at his filter if you want but if you think I'm scum I don't see the point since I would just use TMI and make a case calling him his true alignment Don't remember doing this already ?
On February 13 2016 09:07 Wartrukk wrote: I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak
On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu?
|
Loving that ninja vote of confirmed scum (=
|
EZ TBH no effort from him
|
Alright see you later ^^ kinda sure Wartruk is the last one but we have time to talk about it.
|
Don't have time to play before like 1 hour before deadline. Don't think I'm the kill anyway so I have time to reread the game before EOD3. ^^ Regardless of reads, here is what we should do regarding the setup: We're 4v1 right now. IF MEDIC PROTECTS SOMEONE TONIGHT => we suddenly have 2 lynches so we use them. IF THERE IS ONE KILL: We will be 3v1 MYLO. I think we sleep so there is one more kill, 'cause nobody except kush is even near the confirmed town status. And if there is a protection during the next night, we have one alive confirmed townie. When we're at 2v1 LYLO, doc should immediately claim if still alive so we reduce the lynch candidates pool to 2 people.
|
I guess it's not really "regardless of reads" since us sleeping in MYLO is better BECAUSE we don't have 2 confirmed townies.
|
On February 15 2016 23:04 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: Robik you want to leave the fate of this game up to garg, warty? Why not you think they're dumb ? And I don't want to do nothing during the whole D3, I want us to solve the game the best we can BUT one additional kill is more info when nobody is confirmed town.
|
On February 16 2016 02:42 keanuisgod wrote: Why NL now and not last D2? Situation feels exactly the same.
Don't see much benefit in having scum pick and choose which townie to kill in 2 nights in a row, unless your plan is to REALLY count on a doc save at some point (to confirm townies).
Plus I think doc should claim tomorrow. Him claiming makes no difference on who he can save at a potential N3 night, but we'll have a confirmed townie on D3, or the suspects get reduced to 2 (if there is CC). I would have advocated sleeping yesterday if I had no idea who to lynch; Vlad was very likely scum though. I think Wartruk is scum but it's not as strong a feeling, especially with your weird read on Vlad. It's a GOOD thing if doc save someone N3 as we begin the day with one conf town + one claim. So it's not useless to sleep + hope for protect and see who scum kills. BTW this is only necessary 'cause you and I are not confirmed town to others' eyes, if one of eyes was universally townread it would be pretty pointless to sleep.
|
Man Keanu is just there ALL the time, probably means he's town TBH. Like, even super good scums just needs to AFK 12 hours in a row sometimes 'cause scum is stresfull, but Kaenu has answered to every other post in the game I'm pretty sure. p:
|
Wartruk a big problem I have with you is that you're like:
On February 11 2016 05:33 Wartrukk wrote: Vald is coming out of the gate strong andI think that's towny, especially if he replaced in on short notice. Saitama had a weird early game and I had him as leanscum last night but I haven't read too closely the 30 or so posts from last night. Then I talk to you and you're like:
On February 13 2016 09:07 Wartrukk wrote: I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak
On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu? Then Kaenu talks to you and you're like:
On February 14 2016 07:51 Wartrukk wrote:Show nested quote +Regarding robik, he just came into the game so it'd be hard to gauge alignment just on a couple of posts. However, I'm getting strong suspicions on him being scum. His demeanor sticks out in a weird manner, since he JUST came into the game and is acting like he solved everything and he caught the scumteam and has NO doubts whatsoever about anything .... when it's MYLO. I'd presume he'd be MORE confused than us in this game since he missed D1 and a lot of stuff, not that he'd be more confident than ANY of us. Also, if I assume he's town the way he made his reads feels weird. Like, Garga and Warty seem "likely town so I'll leave them alone" (which to be honest is somewhat what I did with the "Standby" pile up there). So from his POV the ONLY thing left is accuse me of being scum (assuming NNN is town and scum have no way of believably go against him). His case is bad, the way he approached his read on me is weird too. It feels like the only reason he's FOSing me is because of PoE, not because he thinks I'm scum in an independent manner. From my POV, if Garga and Warty are still in that Standby(me)/Likely town(robik) pile, then it doesn't make sense for robik to go after me with such conviction instead of taking a step back and figure out if his actual (admitted by him as not strong) reads on Garga and Warty. This makes perfect sense if he's scum and found some "scummy" posts of mine to scapegoat while not wanting to go against the flow and accuse someone of Garga/Warty. If he's scum with Valdi then Gargy/Warty/me(obs) are all town so he HAS to pick one to scapegoat, and apparently I have the scummiest posts. He could also be scum with one of Gargy/Warty so in that case he'd obviously have some agenda (not to push his buddy for instance). Also I had my (very small) suspicions of unholy back on D1 (which I think I already posted), so it doesn't feel out of place for robik to be scum (considering unholy). I did notice he gave me my well deserved townread when nobody else did, but it's weird that you say he could be with valdi but that would imply you are the scummiest of the reest of the townies. This is incorrect, going for the low hanging fruit is often called out on TL from what I see. Yeah, fuck, I'll read robik's filter brb
On February 14 2016 07:57 Wartrukk wrote:Show nested quote +On February 13 2016 09:14 Iwasrobik wrote:On February 13 2016 09:06 Wartrukk wrote: So on first read I hate gargamel and want him to be died. He quite obviously cares less about this game than I do and that's just fucked I had a townread on him for some reason reading the thread. Let's see why. On February 10 2016 12:26 GargamelxD wrote: cant really take any posts seriously so far, no analysis possible becouse it still seems like standard banter I first had a scumread for this post. On February 11 2016 15:57 GargamelxD wrote: he could be SL maybe, either that or ls
either way i think goldrom is VA and i want to kill him with fire
##Vote 77Goldrom Oh yeah, he was one of the first to take a firm stance for the lynch. Town points. On February 11 2016 21:45 GargamelxD wrote: i dont see any issues with unholy as he just postponed his actual play which i also did, and his entrance wasnt as awkward as roms. he actually took interest into what was happening and gave a bit of his opinion on smurf hunting.
in rom you have a guy who apologizes for being late, claims his role, asks about the latest news and in the next post acts like he doesnt care. Not scumreading me when I was an easy ML. + Having strong opinions in his few posts. Not confirmed town but likely IMO. Oh yeah I remember thinking this made sense at the time but this is actually such a bullshit reason. "Having strong opinions" and "taking a firm stance" but these things are backed up by nothing in garg's filter, it's like robik just grabbed a couple posts that sound good and called garg town. + Show Spoiler +also "Not confirmed town but likely IMO." Is some weird language to use for some random posts
On February 15 2016 05:45 Wartrukk wrote: Right now I'm thinking robik and garg is the most likely scumteam OH YEAH WHAT HAPPENED TO THE VALD IS SCUM CAUSE HE ONLY POSTED USELESS STUFF READ ?
Then 1 hour before deadline you're like:
On February 15 2016 07:20 Wartrukk wrote: Hm, should I switch so scum can't last minute hammer or what? Probably So super convinced Vald is scum apparently. WHAT HAPPENED TO THE FUCKING GARG + ROBIK SCUMTEAM THERE ?????? It seems very much like you're only talking to talk and please the guy you're talking to, and have no real reads.
|
On February 15 2016 07:58 Wartrukk wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2016 07:55 Iwasrobik wrote:On February 15 2016 07:53 Wartrukk wrote:On February 15 2016 07:51 keanuisgod wrote: What do you think Valdi will flip right now?
Tell us ALL your thoughts about Valdi, before he flips and this will be invalid Off the top of my head 'he posted a few times day 1 and I liked the posts at the time' I'll have a gander at his filter if you want but if you think I'm scum I don't see the point since I would just use TMI and make a case calling him his true alignment Don't remember doing this already ? On February 13 2016 09:07 Wartrukk wrote: I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu? Never did it Why did you say "I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read." if you didn't read his filter ?
|
On February 16 2016 07:26 Wartrukk wrote:Show nested quote +On February 16 2016 07:24 Iwasrobik wrote:On February 15 2016 07:58 Wartrukk wrote:On February 15 2016 07:55 Iwasrobik wrote:On February 15 2016 07:53 Wartrukk wrote:On February 15 2016 07:51 keanuisgod wrote: What do you think Valdi will flip right now?
Tell us ALL your thoughts about Valdi, before he flips and this will be invalid Off the top of my head 'he posted a few times day 1 and I liked the posts at the time' I'll have a gander at his filter if you want but if you think I'm scum I don't see the point since I would just use TMI and make a case calling him his true alignment Don't remember doing this already ? On February 13 2016 09:07 Wartrukk wrote: I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu? Never did it Why did you say "I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read." if you didn't read his filter ? What do you mean? You posted:
On February 13 2016 09:07 Wartrukk wrote: I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak Then:
On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu? Did you read Vlad's filter between these two posts ?
|
It doesn't make sense. Why would you post "I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read." if you didn't read his filter ? Why would you wait 11 minutes to post that ?
|
So you posted "I will read valdiano's filter since he's getting a lot of flak". Then you DIDNT READ his filter and waited 11 minutes doing NOTHING. Then you posted "I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read." ?????????????????????
|
|
|
|