I'm pretty sure Keir and Kita are both town. I don't care about numbers or picks honestly; mostly because I won't have time to organize anything and people never follow it anyway. Regardless, numbers/roles don't matter now; just find scum.

FYI, Onegu is scum.

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 04:02 GMT

#309

Why what?

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 04:05 GMT

#312

On January 19 2016 13:03 Breshke wrote:
Sorry. Why is onegu scum

He's trolling wrong.

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 04:41 GMT

#316

I'm 50/50 on Damdred but kinda think he's town. Idk why though.

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 04:43 GMT

#318

On January 19 2016 13:42 Keirathi wrote:
There are only 20 unique first numbers, and 22 players, so there is going to be some overlap.

Might as well be me overlapping with Onegu. He's giving himself an excuse already to take an awful shot on me. So we can see if he has the balls to scumclaim in the thread and actually do it.

Anyone's posts stick out to you?

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 05:10 GMT

#321

Interesting but meh IMO.

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 05:39 GMT

#324

I'm going to guess the mysterious challenger thing fucks with that a bit more than normal but idk. I haven't read the roles list.

geript

9644 Posts

January 19 2016 07:39 GMT

#333

FYI I think I put in 17/12. I'm not changing either.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 05:53 GMT

#856

I'll be honest. I'm going to pick CPR doc. I'm town and each of my last games (and analysis) I've pretty much targeted only scum. Plus, it's a roll where I can kill scum because I'm pretty shitty at making cases and convincing people.

Palmer, I'm 99% sure you're wrong about Keir.

Also I don't like disinfo. IDK why, but when I was reading while driving back from work (before my phone battery stopped that) I saw a post of his that I didn't like. But I'm not 100% b/c I think there was a game where I had the same feeling for what I think are similar reasons and he was town.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 05:53 GMT

#857

Oh and copcake is town too. Damdred's list felt "right" but I'm having a hard time calling him town for some reason.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 05:58 GMT

#858

FWIW, I don't like Rels. For having so many townreads, he's kinda wasting his time one random peripheral shit and doing nothing at all. Like I feel like I should have an idea of who he's looking at or interested in; in the least I think he should be trying to town circle a bit more and he's just kinda blah.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 06:00 GMT

#859

I do find it a little funny that Greymist put the TL mafia logo with numbers that can't be picked in the game...

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 06:03 GMT

#860

Oh yeah and Breshke is town. Also, only Breshke should pick Watson. I think that's a really good role for him and Watson should claimed Holmes' sanity ASAP; I'm 50/50 on him claiming Moriarty's.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 06:25 GMT

#861

On January 20 2016 03:15 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

Vivax is mafia. Not simply because he refuses to cooperate but because he refuses to cooperate AND that is everything he brings to the table.

I get this sentiment, I think it's actually one of the key points in Boardwalk. But looking at Vivax filter I just don't really see it. He's basically afk. He could still be scum but I just don't think it's valid honestly.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 06:29 GMT

#862

On January 20 2016 14:53 geript wrote:
Oh and copcake is town too. Damdred's list felt "right" but I'm having a hard time calling him town for some reason.

To expand, in looking at it I don't like Damdred's TR on Rels and I'm kinda 50/50 on his TR of Koshi. Having read Rels' filter, it doesn't quite feel right. It's a little meh really but I'm not feeling him this game like I was in the abortion of a game.

geript

9644 Posts

January 20 2016 07:00 GMT

#865

On January 20 2016 15:35 Keirathi wrote:
I think my problem with Damdred is that he's one of my favorite town players because he's....inisghtful? I guess is the worst for it. And he hasn't been so far.

Step it up, Damdy.

Also hey geript, I didn't expect anyone to be around more tonight