Gonzaw <3 I had forgotten about Artanis/hadn't felt like I had enough evidence to go after him. That part that really rang a bell for me was that He's made a few posts that are like three paragraphs long so they look like a solid post but in fact don't say anything... my dear old friend CWC (contributing without contributing) doing work.
I'd like more people to comment on my shevlocke case which, while I feel it is weaker than the artanis case, is my number two suspect.
I also feel that vivax is scummy, however he's like number three on my list.
Two people I want opinions on are Strongandbig and sharrant. Not sure what to make of either of them atm.
On April 08 2013 04:47 gonzaw wrote: [...] Also, yamato+rayn+Sharrant, i'm disappoint son You guys spent I dunno how many hours discussing shit in the drafting phase, yet now you guys disappear and do shit (I guess this applies to yamato the least, but I don't remember him being as active as before, at least comparing to Mocsta for instance).
I want to highlight this section of the post, there are a lot of people who were very active or even slightly active during the picking phase but have now dropped out of sight. Now I could understand that a townie would be discouraged if they didn't get the role they wanted and are now a bit less invested in the game, however this is also an excellent cover for scum to lurk under.
I'd love if yamato, rayn, sharrant, obviousone, and snoman could give us their thoughts on the current cases being discussed. What do you think of Artanis? What do you think of Shevlocke? What do you think of Vivax? Are there any people you consider scum who are not currently up for lynch today?
@austin: you and gonzaw both bring up good points that certain people have cases made about them and then the thread seems to forget or gloss over them. Regardless of who gets lynched today, I think we really need to remember the other suspects from today and address them tomorrow because you're right, there has not been a lot of discussion about people who I feel are very good lynch options.
On April 08 2013 05:11 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: @austin: you and gonzaw both bring up good points that certain people have cases made about them and then the thread seems to forget or gloss over them. Regardless of who gets lynched today, I think we really need to remember the other suspects from today and address them tomorrow because you're right, there has not been a lot of discussion about people who I feel are very good lynch options.
You have had a lot of posts I've liked, and we have agreed on a couple things this game that make me feel good about you.
But this post in particular feels weak. You earlier wanted to lynch artanis based on gonzaw's case, with shelvocke as a second choice based on your case and perhaps some of what I brought up. Now you go buddy-mode and say that there are good points being made about "people have cases made about them" that get forgotten, when the "people" at issue are your top and second lynch candidate allegedly.
That seems...very uninvested in your reads?
I've been suspicious of artanis since the beginning of the game, gonzaw's case crystallized a lot of what I was feeling. The second part of my post is garbled I guess. I was basically trying to say today we kill one of shevlocke/artanis and tomorrow kill the other. I want to avoid the thread "forgetting" about people (and by people I'm really just talking about shevlocke/artanis). Keep in mind that just because the people are my top two candidates doesn't mean that they're everyone's top two candidates, there's plenty of time for the cases to get buried and forgotten.
On April 08 2013 09:06 Palmar wrote: I still think VE is scum.
Disengaged VE has almost always been scum.
I actually am starting to feel this might be the case. My previous read on VE was based on the activity level and contributions at the time I had read the thread. Now it's been uncharacteristically long since I've seen him in the thread and like Palmar says, VE is more likely to be scum when he isn't here as much.
VE I'm gonna need some good quality reads out of you as well as some serious contribution or I'm gonna start thinking you don't care. And if you don't care then you're scum.
we can wifom what scum want us to think by the gonzaw kill from here till kingdom come but we won't get anywhere. Ultimately we need to stick with artanis as he has been consistently scummy and pushed by a now confirmed townie.
@Yamato. I'm really tired with you calling me scum and never backing it up, come up with some reasons or shut up.
On April 08 2013 13:56 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: we can wifom what scum want us to think by the gonzaw kill from here till kingdom come but we won't get anywhere. Ultimately we need to stick with artanis as he has been consistently scummy and pushed by a now confirmed townie.
@Yamato. I'm really tired with you calling me scum and never backing it up, come up with some reasons or shut up.
Read on Yam pls.
Town, null, scum?
He's an idiot for one, right now I have a lot of people (Artanis, Shevlocke, Vivax, Sharrant, VE etc.) who I care more about than yamato. He's been largely afk after an active start. I hate using this because I feel like it's a cop out but I'm just gonna put him as null and come back to it when it actually matters.
On April 08 2013 13:56 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: we can wifom what scum want us to think by the gonzaw kill from here till kingdom come but we won't get anywhere. Ultimately we need to stick with artanis as he has been consistently scummy and pushed by a now confirmed townie.
@Yamato. I'm really tired with you calling me scum and never backing it up, come up with some reasons or shut up.
Read on Yam pls.
Town, null, scum?
He's an idiot for one, right now I have a lot of people (Artanis, Shevlocke, Vivax, Sharrant, VE etc.) who I care more about than yamato. He's been largely afk after an active start. I hate using this because I feel like it's a cop out but I'm just gonna put him as null and come back to it when it actually matters.
I have you as scum because you're commenting on me calling you scum a million times and yet your contributions to anything in the thread are shallow at best.
Do something.
eh I guess you're still stupid. Of course I'm commenting on you calling me scum, you've called me scum but never justified it, your reasons for calling me scum are self fulfilling. I've contributed ten times more than you have to the actual relevant discussion that has occurred today.
Done talking to you until you can either a) write an actual case about me or b) come up with some interesting reads (other than sheeping me and gonzaw on artanis).
mkay caller I'm gonna take your word on this. I'm in class now but and I need to reevaluate VE before I decided between him or shevlocke for our lynch. Expect something in a few hours.
You're the one holding paper sounding like an idiot. The rest of the thread is the guy sitting in back who actually can't believe that something that stupid was said.