Purgatory Mafia - Page 3
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
Cwave We also have a seer who in my opinion has the most important power of the game, namely the identification of angels! As of such, please don't roleclaim for now as mentioned in the pre-game discussion for with 3 factions in this game, 2 factions will instantly try to kill you. Ok, weird role to choose the most important power of. Unless you're a demon. I think this is a good hypothetical question to answer. One everyone should answer! Dikrzor for me at the moment. For you Palmar & Syllo, who would you pop right now if you had to? Cwave, what do you think about risk? Do you think his plan was reasonable? What plan do you mean? Not too bad of a plan since you do tend to create good ripples in the water. And with ripples comes information. Or this one? Buddying with Palmar, possible scumbuddies? The exchange about risk.nuke and his plan sounds especially contrived. @ Risknuke. 6 voted on you at the moment and it seems 5 people haven't voted yet, including myself. Other then your defense that you "got annoyed with meta in the face", any reason i shouldn't vote you? Seems such a waste to hang someone like you for information as suggested by other people in here. While i await your asnwer im parking my vote on Erandorr. Main reason is this post which puts Erandorr along side RoL for me in terms of bad/useless. ##VOTE: Erandorr Not wanting to vote risk.nuke? I'm going to say that if we lynch risk.nuke and he flips demon, Cwave is most probably the last one. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
On January 10 2012 08:57 Blazinghand wrote: Np Mr wiggs. Let's bury this guy. no your point is dumb he will always claim he thought his idea was a good idea. Let's not "bury this guy" because he derped for a post. I think he's one of the most open and active members so far in posting his reads/trying to get people lynched, and I think he's probably town, even if some of his cases are bad. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
... ... I'll still rather want to lynch risk.nuke first today though. What do you think of him blazing? | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
Maybe I'm just tunneling risk though. I just don't want another situation like in XLVIII where we were so close to lynching annul for 3 days and end up vote-switching at the last minute every single time to someone else. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
On January 10 2012 08:57 Blazinghand wrote: Np Mr wiggs. Let's bury this guy. no your point is dumb he will always claim he thought his idea was a good idea. Blazing, you tell me this post isn't misleading at all? Especially when mr wiggles was ending up talking about layabout at the last part of his post just before yours? And spaackle, what exactly of your point still stands, after it's clear that I'm not defending RoL, but rather layabout? | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
On January 10 2012 09:10 Blazinghand wrote: Refallen do you think there are any circumstances under which a town RoL would suggest that plan? RoL is a pretty smart guy. Yes. In the pre-game someone suggested a mass role-claim too. It isn't impossible for a town RoL to suggest the plan, and at the very least it seems that he has thought through it enough to address some common criticisms. But that's not the point. I rather stay on risk.nuke because I think he's a better lynch, I remember the last time you tried one of your hustlin' cases, though I do agree that RoL needs to do more this cycle. Just because I voted for risk.nuke does not mean I think RoL to be town. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
And you're missing syllo's point, risk is MORE LIKELY to flip scum than RoL, and thus, he is a BETTER lynch. If we had 5 lynches per day we could lynch anyone who looks suspicious, but with only one, we have to choose the one that has the highest probability of making a scum flip. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
k. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
Also, if you're still on that hidden vote thing, I derped, I said it, I stopped doing it. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
RoL 1. Lurker -----> Scummy 2. Proposed anti-town plan ---> Scummy = 100% Scum Problem with number 1; as he said, he was busy, and it was due to Responsibility Mafia being at endgame. Obviously he chose to devote more time to that. Who's to say he isn't busy with real life after that, and that he's just bluffing? And again, proposing anti-town plan does not immediately = scummy. Yes, it was bad for town. But I feel the way that he presented his plan, tried to defend it, in effect, sticking his head out in plain sight, generating a lot of attention, is not something a scum would risk. Especially if scum knew the plan was this anti-town and thus having little chance of getting actually taken up. It is much more likely that he was considering the plan in his head and just neglected to consider some aspect to it. I'm sure if he was scum his teammates would have stopped him from proposing such a plan with this obvious a gap. So what I'm essentially saying is, no, he's not 100% going to flip scum. Does he deserve a look? Yes. Can he flip scum? Possibly. But not as likely as risk.nuke flipping scum. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
Refallen
452 Posts
welp. Sorry for tunnelling you, risk. | ||
Refallen
452 Posts
| ||
| ||