VOTE COAGULATION
OOPS!
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
VOTE COAGULATION OOPS! | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
1) Grfy thinks it's GM fishing for blues and that the plan doesn't work for town 2) GM thinks it will promote activity and that it's a pro-town move (did I get this right?) Let's take a step back and lets move on to pressuring inactives. The newbies I can understand, but JBright, you really should have said something by now. ##Vote: JBright | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 24 2011 01:48 OriginalName wrote: Show nested quote + On February 24 2011 01:34 OriginalName wrote: He seems to want reads to be isolated when they should be posted in the thread. This is seems scummier and scummier to me but i will reserve my judgement for now. -_- Use of PM to ask questions directed at one specific person isn't "isolation" it's scumhunting. He isn't preventing you from posting both in PMs and on the thread. If anything, if you only reply in PM and not in thread, that's a bit suspicious to the person PMing you. Mass pming everyone to ask questions that aren't blue directed could either be townie trying to scum hunt or a mafia trying REALLLY hard to play infiltration role. Grfy's vet claim is a pretty good play if he's town i'd say.... 1) it gets reactions from people 2) mafia has to be on their toes, is he really vet or is he lying? Do we hit him or let him live? The only thing that worries me about it is the mass claim part to me. While most veteran players won't and will merely respond with a what?? you so crazy!!, some newbies with blue roles might actually do it and claim (even some vets are stupid enough to blind claim -_-) For that, I'm suspicious and that's why I'm asking pointed questions to him, specifically in thread. I could have done it in PMs too, which i think is what Gmarshal is doing, applying pressure. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 24 2011 02:21 Jackal58 wrote: Show nested quote + On February 24 2011 02:14 chaoser wrote: On February 24 2011 01:48 OriginalName wrote: On February 24 2011 01:34 OriginalName wrote: He seems to want reads to be isolated when they should be posted in the thread. This is seems scummier and scummier to me but i will reserve my judgement for now. -_- Use of PM to ask questions directed at one specific person isn't "isolation" it's scumhunting. He isn't preventing you from posting both in PMs and on the thread. If anything, if you only reply in PM and not in thread, that's a bit suspicious to the person PMing you. Mass pming everyone to ask questions that aren't blue directed could either be townie trying to scum hunt or a mafia trying REALLLY hard to play infiltration role. Grfy's vet claim is a pretty good play if he's town i'd say.... 1) it gets reactions from people 2) mafia has to be on their toes, is he really vet or is he lying? Do we hit him or let him live? The only thing that worries me about it is the mass claim part to me. While most veteran players won't and will merely respond with a what?? you so crazy!!, some newbies with blue roles might actually do it and claim (even some vets are stupid enough to blind claim -_-) For that, I'm suspicious and that's why I'm asking pointed questions to him, specifically in thread. I could have done it in PMs too, which i think is what Gmarshal is doing, applying pressure. If he is a vet scum just have to do a role reversal on him and he's "hit" His claim makes no sense in this set up. And if he's just green? They just wasted 1 KP. It makes mafia doubt and because of that, he can play a bit more aggressive and out in the open, though that might be just in his character... | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 24 2011 06:42 annul wrote: actually in fact, the only way you can claim "ive been really scummy so far" is if you saw my play last night, and if you did, then you know i already explained that vote. interesting. Maybe you should do some reading of your own since I've already responded to your point about me already, as have many others. You looking like a dumb town, or a crazy red playing super aggressive. Either way, you better step up your game fast. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
Will reread and post tomorrow, just took a midterm (aced it) and finished a 6 page paper in 2 hours and running on no sleep. Night all, hopefully we have a more peaceful town tomorrow. Angry town=town not working at it's fullest. Emotions get the best of us and then mafia can sway us easily. Remember, this is not just a logic game, it's also an emotional one. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
Firstly, Annul: At present, annul is bad for town whether he's mafia or not...I mean there's not helping town and there's being detrimental to town. Making the thread into a heated mud slinging battle=not very good atmosphere to be catching red in. Promoting discussion is fine, promoting flaming is not. It just lets mafia blend in and take sides and have an easy way of "contributing to discussion". I know he can do better too, it's just a question of why isn't he i guess. I hate policy lynches but if it keeps going this way... I'm willing to have him as a fall back lynch if no one else comes up. That being said, icemac, what's up not analyzing? Whether it's "fluff" or not (I don't really think the topics people are discussing are fluff) there's a lot to talk about. You can talk about the situation in general (why did this convo pop up? if this is mafia talking why would they do this? etc. etc,) Or you can even explain why it's fluff. You kinda just say it's fluff and bounce. How the heck am I red? Just because I'm smart enough to take a bipartisan approach to day 1 and not listen to over analysis and red-analysis doesn't mean I'm scum playing the middle of the road. I actually use to play this way too cause I figured I needed more info before making a call, but making a call by itself is helpful for town. When we look back on past events, we can say, ah ha, this is where he stood in the situation, given what's happened so far, i think he's town/mafia/etc. It's like leaving a mark for all to see. As opposed to saying nothing about anything and then you don't leave ANY mark. How is town suppose to read you if you're just not leaving a mark? By thinking hmm why didn't he want to leave a mark...SCUMMM. See, not helpful at all. Gryffindor: I don't know if he lied or not. Maybe it was just a misunderstanding in PMs where he thought RoL/MK said something they didn't actually mean. Unless RoL says in thread he 100% lied, I'm going to read it as such. His list, I think, is just him giving into popular sentiment. I don't think it points to him as being red, more like he's seeing that it COULD be beneficial. Also, how is it that you can't correlate my idea with his cell idea? Just because we have cells scumhunting, doesn't mean we can't PM a confirmed on d2 or d3. I do not see how it is black vs white, when there is in fact a lot of room for gray area. This statement by him is pretty good, I agree that both can be combined if needed. Makes me think he's green cause he's willing to compromise instead of just toeing the line which is much easier to do as mafia than to reach across the aisle. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 25 2011 03:59 Jackal58 wrote: When your parents caught you lying what was the first thing you did? Get mad nervous and make up a bullshit story? | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
##vote annul | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
I just asked RoL how the KP works to try and figure out how many mafia there are and he said mafia can round up. Assuming 6 mafia like people mentioned before, 5 left, that's 1+/5x4 = 3 KP. That means they can still kill 3 and have .5KP left over to frame/cover. 100% DON'T CLAIM if you've found a townie or a vet, it's too risky, they could be GF or covered. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 26 2011 12:20 Jackal58 wrote: Because it needs repeating. + Show Spoiler + The following need to step up their game: Gofarman - 8 posts astroorion - 3 posts JBright - 4 posts ICanFlyLow - 2 posts ohN - 3 posts why - 6 posts CubEdIn - 6 posts LastArgument - 7 posts Fewer that 10 posts this far in is inexcusable. Cubed I know you can do better than that. I concur @ICanFlyLow I understand it's a little intimidating to see 20+ pages of discussion and whatnot, but you need to post a bit more. By a bit more I mean A LOT more. A very easy way to do that is to go to someone's post, click profile, click his postcount and then open all his posts for this game and read through them and then analyse what they have said. Pretty simple. Currently you have....2 posts. @Gofarman He's looking for a replacement, don't know what's going to happen here @ohN Although he's posted very little, they're pretty good posts by themselves. + Show Spoiler + On February 23 2011 19:21 ohN wrote: 'Just finished catching up My thoughts: Cells are a good idea but GMarshal giving us predetermined groups that he thinks we should work with is pretty scummy. They weren't just like 1-3, 4-6 either, he moved them around to his liking. Not a good candidate for day1 lynch because I don't feel that that alone is enough to incriminate him but definitely FoS on him. I dont see how people think + Show Spoiler + On February 23 2011 12:40 chaoser wrote: Ok, so like Gmarshal said, we shouldn't depend on blues this game. Especially since RoL specifically said this game was to punish us for what happened in Salam. At the same thing, I don't think the mafia powers are all THAT powerful. Let them frame away, that's one less death to worry about. PMs are allowed but PLEASE don't just give out crazy info in them (roleclaim, etc.). The point of town is not to have 1 leader controlling everything but small circles that are separated so that if one goes down, the others can still operate. Let's all work together and not let a few players handle all the work (which always seems to happen). This means contributing pleaseee. Him noting that mafia isn't that powerful is something anybody could point out. Role reversal has huge potential but only if mafia has a confirmed blue. They still have to give up an entire kp to use it so they will not be open to using it without being absolutely sure. Role reversal on a townie does nothing except waste a kp. I'll probably end up voting for someone who hasn't posted anything useful or that guy who thought annul was inactive(lol). and + Show Spoiler + On February 25 2011 10:26 ohN wrote: Icemac is probably town. Bad d1 lynch target. Looks more like a bad/aggressive player than scum. I'm still not convinced annul is a good lynch. Show nested quote + On February 25 2011 07:25 LSB wrote: Storytime! Why Annul was an easy read in XXXV 1) He mad up stuff and pushed stuff that didn't exist Check, this game he's pushing GMarshal, saying GMarshal is clear mafia, although there is literally nothing in his accusation 2) Besides responses, he posted nothing else Look at Annul's posts. How many of his posts deal with things other than Gmarshal or defending himself? I can't find any. Annul's not pushing GM that hard, he simply pointed out that GM had a bad idea and is calling him out on it. I don't think he ever said "GM is clear mafia." GM DID propose an arguably terrible plan; how come nobody else is calling him out for that? Annul's not looking any more scum than GM here in my eyes. Barundar's accusation of Jackal is definitely not convincing but it's not utter crap either. It's an interesting point to look back to in the near future. Slight FoS on Jackal imo. And finally, why is gryff not getting lynched? Show nested quote + On February 24 2011 15:20 gryffindor wrote: the HOST actually told me it was a good idea. Blatant lie here. Show nested quote + On February 23 2011 17:26 gryffindor wrote: On February 23 2011 13:19 GMarshal wrote: for arguments sake going to create analysis cells, use them for informational analysis (even assuming I were scum there is no way) I could ensure each has a mafia member in it as there isn't enough mafia to go around (I am trying to put at least 1 TL vet in each) as the game progresses and people die we can have new cells form. (also you are free to create your own parallel cells) 1. Coagulation, LSB, gryffindor 2 GMarshal, seRapH, OriginalName 3 Mr. Wiggles, ICanFlyLow, kevconsim 4 Barundar, LastArgument , why 5 darmousseh, Ser Aspi, Kenpachi 6 Gofarman, chaoser, ohN 7 astroorion, CubEdIn, Jackal58 8 Beneather, annul, Conversion 9 icemac, Foolishness, LunarDestiny 10 deconduo, kitaman27, JBright This is just a suggestion, but I think it is a good one, discuss This would get us raped by the role reverser, and is really a scummy idea unvote; ##Vote: GMarshal Show nested quote + On February 24 2011 22:14 gryffindor wrote: Cell 1, Cell leader: Coagulation+ Show Spoiler + 1. 5. Jackal58 2. 17. astroorion 3. 1. Coagulation Cell 2, Cell leader: kitaman27+ Show Spoiler + 4. 19. Gofarman 5. 21. kitaman27 6. 12. icemac Cell 3, Cell leader: IDC, they're all competant+ Show Spoiler + 7. 6. Kenpachi 8. 2. LSB 9. 26. LunarDestiny Cell 4, Cell leader: Barundar+ Show Spoiler + 10. 30. LastArgument 11. 3. Barundar 12. 9. gryffindor Cell 5, Cell leader: deconduo+ Show Spoiler + 13. 16. ohN 14. 28. deconduo 15. 8. annul Cell 6, Cell leader: Foolishness+ Show Spoiler + 16. 18. Foolishness 17. 27. Ser Aspi 18. 22. kevconsim Cell 7, Cell leader: Seraph/Mr. Wiggles+ Show Spoiler + 19. 11. Beneather 20. 15. seRapH 21. 24. Mr. Wiggles Cell 8, Cell leader: OriginalName+ Show Spoiler + 22. 14. JBright 23. 23. ICanFlyLow 24. 13. OriginalName Cell 9, Cell leader: Chaoser+ Show Spoiler + 25. 7. darmousseh 26. 25. chaoser 27. 20. Conversion MaxwellE Cell 10, Cell leader: Cubedin+ Show Spoiler + 28. 4. CubEdIn 29. 29. why 30. 10. GMarshal Now, the "leader" to me is someone who needs to go out of their way to actually collaborate with the other people in their group. If you don't want to use my list of cells, and want to use GMarshal's, whatever. I have a good list I just made right here ready for us to use. Basically, the leaders need to go out of their way to make this work. I am fully confident in these peoples abilities to report what is going on within your cell, and to hold people accountable. Wait what. ##Vote: gryffindor | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
1. Barundar attempts to redirect the lynch off of annul Wouldn't mafia, if they were trying to redirect off annul, find it easier to pick gryf to stack on? He lied multiple times, changed from no to the PMs to yes to PMs but with his own list. I mean, that's a much easier case to be made than to do it on jackal right? It doesn't make sense to try to push jackal is a viable lynch candidate for mafia when the big juicy target of gryf is there. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
Priority 1: Automatic night 1 snipes if possible These players are proven scumhunters LSB Foolishness So basically you claimed town, you didn't even say "good players" you said "proven scumhunters" aka keep us around cause we'll help town win please don't lynch us or town is fucked. Not to mention you scream for medic protection, making it seem like you're town. Basically if we are going to lynch a priority 1 person, the analysis must be far better than a priority 3 person, because if we're wrong, that would be far worse for the town. If we're wrong about you being town and you're actually mafia then it's far worse for the town as well. The whole time you've been building up this image of, don't lynch me town, you're going to get dicked cause you need me via subtle threats to town. BC's guide has stated that we need multiple leaders and not to depend on one guy. By trying to consolidate power in a way that's subtle and a bit underhanded, aren't you just making the town depend on you? That's the worse possible thing for town to do, especially since there's a decent amount of newbies who will sheep. What are you trying to pull? I don't know if you're red but I do know that if barundar flips green, you're the first one on my lynch list. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
I don't agree with you LSB, Jackal wasn't an easier choice than Gryf or icemac. I think at that point, no one had voted for Jackal yet, so for mafia to start a completely new bandwagon instead of using one that already had a decent amount of people in it is weird and not what mafia would do. The only reason mafia would pick jackal over BOTH grfy and icemac is if both of them were mafia and they had to start a new one. So if barundar does flip red, we should pay attention to those two | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 27 2011 05:11 LSB wrote: Show nested quote + On February 27 2011 04:54 chaoser wrote: So basically you claimed town, you didn't even say "good players" you said "proven scumhunters" aka keep us around cause we'll help town win please don't lynch us or town is fucked. Not to mention you scream for medic protection, making it seem like you're town. So what do you think about the actual list? You haven't commented if its a good idea or not. Ad Hominem arguments don't count. In addition, how is the list consolidating power? It's not reliant on me at all, in fact, the purpose of the list is so that when I'm dead, people will have an idea of what the mafia is doing and what to pay attention to. I love the list. It's awesome, it helps direct those that are newbies and also paints us an easy picture to see what the status of the game is like currently. It makes me think you're either super pro town or you're doing a power play as mafia, which i know you like to do. Basically I'm acknowledging you're a good player. But if you're mafia, then I want to note these little things and point them out to people so that if we need to in the future, we can come back and look at you again. I'm not saying the list itself is consolidating power, i'm saying that you're dropping little hints everywhere that you should be protected, that if you die then town will be losing a valuable asset and it'll be in a deeper hole than if you were alive. I'm reading it as subtle threats to town. | ||
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On February 27 2011 10:57 icemac wrote: Show nested quote + On February 27 2011 10:29 bumatlarge wrote: Well I read into the whole annul thing, and it doesn't seem to be an organized bus. Especially with that little squirming performance, but then dropping it quickly in a manner I'd expect from him as scum. I didn't find much to point out on who was leading the accusations, but it does give me a nice ladelful of confidence for the town. Deconduo is not scum I feel, and mostly everyone behind it is likely not. GMarshal is a bit tricky because he seems a little too apologetic, but I've only played with him as town, and he would tend to get apologetic when he isn't inquisitive. Maybe he's just more confident? Anyway, I think annul is probably the better catches for town to get early. I think town would be better served in pressuring the more reserved since that roster seems fairly slim in this game. I like icemac as a lynch target, and others like him that don't quite cut the bill. They are much easier to tell apart then good townie players that keep their mouths in check but speak when it is right, such as ohn. LSB is silly. Oh boy, if ohn is mafia and i'm town, i'm going to quote the hell out of this afterwards. For us to know if you're town, don't you have to be dead? how you going to quote it if you dead? | ||
| ||
Next event in 11h 52m
[ Submit Event ] |
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Sea 6135 Dota 2Hyuk 5400 Bisu 1187 Larva 664 Shine 180 EffOrt 120 Leta 114 Pusan 75 Sharp 70 Sacsri 67 [ Show more ] League of Legends Counter-Strike Other Games Organizations
StarCraft 2 • aXEnki StarCraft: Brood War• intothetv • Gussbus • Kozan • IndyKCrew • LaughNgamez Trovo • Laughngamez YouTube • Migwel • Poblha League of Legends |
The PiG Daily
Rogue vs ByuN
Reynor vs Bunny
NightMare vs Bunny
soO vs Ryung
Kung Fu Cup
ESL Pro Tour
ESL Pro Tour
PassionCraft
ESL Pro Tour
World Team League
ESL Pro Tour
Korean StarCraft League
Afreeca Starleague
hero vs Soulkey
[ Show More ] AfreecaTV Pro Series
Reynor vs Cure
ESL Pro Tour
World Team League
ESL Pro Tour
BSL
Sparkling Tuna Cup
ESL Pro Tour
World Team League
ESL Pro Tour
BSL
ESL Open Cup
ESL Open Cup
ESL Open Cup
|
|