|
United States22154 Posts
On February 03 2011 07:15 Coagulation wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2011 05:23 Beneather wrote:On February 03 2011 05:04 GMarshal wrote: @CubEdln I was just pointing out that Kav seemed to think LD was a really valuable asset to the town, and was wondering if he was so good that he might be worth a DT, you obviously don't think so, and I'm tempted to agree, I also a agree that LD is most likely a SK, however if he is it dosn't really resolve weather bum is blue or not, and I think that we need to know weather he is or not, as if he is red then we know two reds and can probably lower their KP by 1, and if he isn't we need to start using him to hunt reds.
I'll propose one thing, although I don't think that its a great idea, we could hang Beneather (a BG) and find if he is red or green, if he is red then our DT is a phoney, otherwise we have a real DT we can use. At this point I don't know what the value of a BG is compared to a DT.
However all else aside unless LD agrees to help town I agree we should hang him, just because its really likely he is the SK There's really no point why LD should help us he's going to lose anyways. It has been stated before he's just going to kill anyone he wants until we lynch him. I don't understand why you are pushing for LD to kill for the town. For anyone we choose it's just going to be another Death for the town. If we lower the KP as much as possible we'll have more time to find the mafia. If LD dies today 1 Kp taken away now we're down to 2 (If there was only 1 SK) The longer there are more night kills the faster the town is going to lose. This is clearly a post supporting the interests of mafia. Beneather needs to die.
Could you go into a little more detail here? specifically can you rebuff his logic about KPs, and the fact that we kind of suck at hunting scum? I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you about Beneather possibly being scum, but I'd like to hear your reasoning.
|
United States22154 Posts
I'm just going to throw this out there Kav, do you know something about LD that we don't that proves he isn't the SK? if you do then I'll take your word for it, otherwise we have enough evidence to warrant lynching LD, at least in my opinion.
|
United States22154 Posts
I vote we just lynch LD, he is the SK almost guaranteed and he dosn't seem that cooperative, hence he has to go. We also need to figure out the clues from today.
|
United States22154 Posts
Also Mr.Wiggles I find your inactivity to be quite suspicious, as you seemed quite active in clue analysis in the minimafia game (and quite good at it too). So, why is this the first time you are coming out with any significant contribution? Please do an in depth clue analysis, see what you get, try to net us some mafia, however at this point I think your inactivity almost merits a FoS. Have you found anything possibly linking Bumatlarge or beneather to the clues?
I like that you almost confirm that LD is a SK but at this point we were almost sure anyway, could you try to contribute something new? hopefully something that get us some scum
(also there is a reference to moonlight in one of the day posts (day 1 or 2, not sure) which obviously ties in to LD.)
|
United States22154 Posts
Good point, I completely forgot I had that in my profile, but it dosn't matter as I am a townie.
|
United States22154 Posts
On February 04 2011 06:40 Kavdragon wrote: LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOL. I think I know what just happened.
Care to clarify then? I mean I can guess, but still.
|
United States22154 Posts
I hope this is true, as in that case we have a guaranteed lynch. Who claimed to be role-blocked earlier?
|
United States22154 Posts
Finally we get mafia! /happy dance
|
United States22154 Posts
On February 04 2011 07:17 Coagulation wrote: im personally gonna hold kav responsible if this doesnt work out. feels like kav is switching shit around to fullfill an exterior motive
I never thought I would say this, but I actually agree with you on this Kav's insistence on lynching bum first feels odd.
|
United States22154 Posts
we better get enough votes before the deadline
|
United States22154 Posts
and out of them there are 5 who are scum
|
United States22154 Posts
We only have about 3 hours, come on town, we actually have a chance now, get your votes together and lets get the mafia kp down to 1
|
United States22154 Posts
On February 04 2011 09:54 Divinek wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2011 08:24 Coagulation wrote:On February 04 2011 08:13 Divinek wrote:On February 04 2011 08:02 Coagulation wrote: jesus christ divinek we got fucking evidence that bum is scum and your gonna ignore it saying you "dont wanna be a sheep" What the fuck is wrong with you. You have got to be kidding
what evidence do you have? I might have missed it, all i read over the thread were people saying he's scum and there was an analysis posted and it was alright, but not nearly as convincing as 100% sk. Mod confirmed Bum lied oh rofl, well if that's convincing evidence then sure ill take 99% scum over 100% sk seems good enough to me It is pretty convincing evidence,I think someone is incriminating themselves....
|
United States22154 Posts
EBWOP: unless you weren't being sarcastic, in which case I apologize
|
United States22154 Posts
aghhh, I will never get used to no flip
|
United States22154 Posts
/cheer.
3 in one night, not bad!
|
United States22154 Posts
Not to be an ass, but instead of sitting here congratulating ourselves maybe we should try some scum hunting? if we have any dts who uncovered scum now would be a good time to point it out. Otherwise its back to analyzing.
|
United States22154 Posts
On February 06 2011 16:30 Barundar wrote: I think we shouldn't rush it kav. Im as certain as i can be on kenpachi as well, but i would rather not try and rush for a fast win and lose at this point. That seems to me to be the mistake mafia did.
There is always the chance of someone being innocent despite a great analysis, and we can afford more mislynches if lunar dies first. We might be guranteed to win if we hit mafia tonight, but if you think about it, the only way it's possible for us to lose is actually if lunar is alive and he helps mafia.
I fully agree with this, while I'm not sure of kenpachi, as I see it LD has pretty much gone from being a benefit to being a bane to the town, as we really have nothing solid to target him on. Thanks for all the help LD, but if we want to win we can't have you killing off more people at night. (Of course if you want to provide some kind of insightful analysis, it would be much appreciated)
|
United States22154 Posts
Number of mafia does matter IMO as someone was modkilled who could potentially be scum, no point in checking anything else. (what benefit do we get out of checking anything else?)
|
United States22154 Posts
On February 07 2011 23:09 Jackal58 wrote: Ya you're right. Eti307 was mod killed. It's still gonna come back with two Mafia. It just isn't going to say CubEdIn and Divinek along with it.
You are tunneling Jackal, remember what happened when you did that in MiniMafia IV? If you really think they are mafia provide an analysis of what makes you think that. You made a decent case for Divinek, and I'd like to see his reply to it, but opposing the use of the SK dosn't necessarily make him mafia. Also I'd like to hear your case against CubEdln. (Not that I necessarily disagree with your accusations)
|
|
|
|