If you want to go to WIFOM land, then let me just pose this to you:
You said it yourself that if there was a roleblocker, mafia is content Subversion and Aidnai was gathering suspicion during day 2, and that I was pretty much not in the spotlight.
Third day, I could have easily pushed for either of them without fake-claiming. By fake-claiming, I have pretty much put myself in the spotlight where I was pretty safe before. Why go for a risky fake-claim to push for their lynch when I can just as easily push for their lynch without fake-claiming?
Do you see the hole in your thought process now?