Both me and Em have our hands/arms positioned weird... The lighting doesn't help either because I actually have my arm curved inward but you can't really see it.

I mean her arms are huge in the picture :p

Kennigit

Canada19447 Posts

June 01 2009 23:47 GMT

#22

AITheCake you dont need to worry about more pictures. We just don't want to see like 1 pic of "oh hai heres my finished cake" and we have no idea where it came from etc. Looks good, glglgl!

AlTheCake

Canada1071 Posts

June 02 2009 00:17 GMT

#23

On June 02 2009 08:47 Kennigit wrote:
AITheCake you dont need to worry about more pictures. We just don't want to see like 1 pic of "oh hai heres my finished cake" and we have no idea where it came from etc. Looks good, glglgl!

Ah okay, thanks for clearing it up! :3

LeperKahn

Romania1846 Posts

June 02 2009 01:23 GMT

#24

I believe we all must remember to follow the cardinal rule when baking a pretty cake.

XoXiDe

United States620 Posts

June 02 2009 01:23 GMT

#25

just went to grocery store and bought pans, etc.. cant wait to start!

Scaramanga

Australia8091 Posts

June 02 2009 02:16 GMT

#26

Ima make a BC cake, glhf to all that are entering

Amber[LighT]

United States5078 Posts

June 02 2009 04:34 GMT

#27

should i post my cake here or you got it FA?

Geo.Rion

7377 Posts

June 02 2009 05:06 GMT

#28

So Incontrol's ultralisk cake enters this competition? If it does we have a winner i think

Zapdos_Smithh

Canada2620 Posts

June 02 2009 06:34 GMT

#29

On June 02 2009 14:06 Geo.Rion wrote:
So Incontrol's ultralisk cake enters this competition? If it does we have a winner i think

Yeah are previous cakes included? That kinda seems a bit cheap :S

Ftrunkz

Australia2474 Posts

June 02 2009 06:40 GMT

#30

On June 02 2009 15:34 Resonance wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah are previous cakes included? That kinda seems a bit cheap :S

they are, and its not cheap at all, it'd be plain unfair if they weren't allowed, haha.

Scaramanga

Australia8091 Posts

June 02 2009 08:09 GMT

#31

On June 02 2009 14:06 Geo.Rion wrote:
So Incontrol's ultralisk cake enters this competition? If it does we have a winner i think

yeah but my bc cake is > ultralisk cakes

betaben

681 Posts

June 02 2009 08:26 GMT

#32

it is really not fair if the previous cakes are included. That's choosing the competition such that the winners are already decided (almost). you cannot chose a competition where people already have a huge head start and expect it to be fair. That is like choosing the competition to be "LT staff lookalikes" and all the TL staff are allowed to enter.

Liquid`Jinro

Sweden33719 Posts

June 02 2009 09:56 GMT

#33

On June 02 2009 07:20 FuDDx wrote:

Show nested quote +

It was said that any cakes in the Tl-bake off(cough what happened ?cough) could be used here I personally don't see anything wrong with the inclusion of your cake.

It's actually our fault the first TL-Bake Off didn't ever finish

We thought this would be started sooner than it was.

And yes, all cakes from that contest (with a starcraft theme) are allowed to enter.

On June 02 2009 17:26 betaben wrote:
it is really not fair if the previous cakes are included. That's choosing the competition such that the winners are already decided (almost). you cannot chose a competition where people already have a huge head start and expect it to be fair. That is like choosing the competition to be "LT staff lookalikes" and all the TL staff are allowed to enter.

I don't think any of the cakes for that contest took 2 weeks to make.. So maybe it's slightly unfair but not very.

We didn't want to host a cake contest RIGHT after the last one and then have to say "lol you can't enter, come up with something new!!" (especially as we initially had plans to start this *weeks* ago).

On June 02 2009 07:24 Cambium wrote:
So taste is not a judging criterion?

Airmailing me the cakes will significantly increase your chances of winning! Or maybe decrease them as the cake would go sour during transport.

On a more serious note, no, we have no way of judging taste so don't worry about it ^^

AlTheCake

Canada1071 Posts

June 02 2009 11:15 GMT

#34

Nice Kerrigan cake!

Amber[LighT]

United States5078 Posts

June 02 2009 12:49 GMT

#35

On June 02 2009 20:15 AlTheCake wrote:
Nice Kerrigan cake!

was fucking hard to do a half-human via cake frosting

i hope it's at least delicious.

IdrA

United States11541 Posts

June 02 2009 12:50 GMT

#36

a huge head start?
is making cakes a year long process or something?

and that was a terrible analogy

DarkShadowz

Sweden321 Posts

June 02 2009 13:31 GMT

#37

Amazing cakes so far. I would so fail if I joined this competition haha.

FirstBorn

Romania3955 Posts

June 02 2009 13:41 GMT

#38

On June 02 2009 21:50 IdrA wrote:

Show nested quote +

a huge head start?
is making cakes a year long process or something?

and that was a terrible analogy

I agree.

Allowing previously made cakes would only help the new competitors since they already have certain standards imposed.

by the way, the tank cake is just awesome!

Eishi_Ki

Korea (South)1667 Posts

June 02 2009 14:32 GMT

#39

I guess the head start he was referring to was their clearly advanced cake baking skillz.

Aranoi

Canada32 Posts

June 02 2009 15:02 GMT

#40

It might not be fair if the previous cakes were from years ago or something, but given that the bake-off apparently happened right before... there's nothing really analogous to the staff situation.

1) The winners aren't already decided; there's probably going to be a lot more people submitting cakes, especially since the Bake Off didn't have a giant "WANT STARCRAFT 2!?" plastered across the front page, and a bunch of the entries there weren't Starcraft related anyways.

2) It's not actually a huge head start. For one, they didn't intend to be like "hey, I'll submit this in 4 weeks for the SC2 competition!" when they made it, since they didn't know about it. Also, they're DONE the cakes. That is to say, in the end, those cakes were made in the same amount of time as the ones for this competition. If Person A spends 8 hours making a cake today, and person B spends 8 hours on June 12 making a cake, neither of them really had a "head start". The only difference between a shorter and longer time period for the contest is either more time for brainstorming (which doesn't affect things AS much), or more time to potentially bake another cake. Each individual cake submission isn't necessarily affected by the length of the contest or who started when.

3) Even if you disregard all of that, it's still a huge advantage for us because we get to see what the previous standards are. Like, we know what we're up against when we make our cake.

That's such an unbelievable benefit that I want to kiss someone on the TL staff but I won't.