• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 09:25
CEST 15:25
KST 22:25
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
RSL Season 1 - Final Week6[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall12HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)16Code S RO4 & Finals Preview: herO, Rogue, Classic, GuMiho0
Community News
Weekly Cups (July 7-13): Classic continues to roll2Team TLMC #5 - Submission extension1Firefly given lifetime ban by ESIC following match-fixing investigation17$25,000 Streamerzone StarCraft Pro Series announced7Weekly Cups (June 30 - July 6): Classic Doubles7
StarCraft 2
General
RSL Revival patreon money discussion thread Weekly Cups (July 7-13): Classic continues to roll Esports World Cup 2025 - Final Player Roster TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy Team TLMC #5 - Submission extension
Tourneys
RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series $5,100+ SEL Season 2 Championship (SC: Evo) WardiTV Mondays Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response Simple Questions Simple Answers
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 482 Wheel of Misfortune Mutation # 481 Fear and Lava Mutation # 480 Moths to the Flame Mutation # 479 Worn Out Welcome
Brood War
General
Flash Announces Hiatus From ASL BW General Discussion A cwal.gg Extension - Easily keep track of anyone [Guide] MyStarcraft [ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall
Tourneys
[BSL20] Non-Korean Championship 4x BSL + 4x China [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2025 ACS Season 2 Qualifier Small VOD Thread 2.0
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do.
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Path of Exile CCLP - Command & Conquer League Project The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread The Accidental Video Game Porn Archive Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Porn and Stuff Summer Games Done Quick 2025!
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Anime Discussion Thread [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion NBA General Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NHL Playoffs 2024
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Men Take Risks, Women Win Ga…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Trip to the Zoo
micronesia
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 560 users

No true Scotsman Fallacy

Blogs > JieXian
Post a Reply
JieXian
Profile Blog Joined August 2008
Malaysia4677 Posts
October 27 2011 06:43 GMT
#1
I have a question after seeing this being used around here.

If I say American music sucks, you may tell me to stay away from Justin Bieber and Lil Wayne and listen to "true American music"

If I say American food sucks, you may ask me to look further than McDonalds or the crap cooked in a particular crappy restaurant I went to and instead eat "true American food".

If I say American movies suck, you may call me an idiot for only watching Transformers and Twilight and dig deeper for "true American movies"

Nothing against America, I know I'll do the same if you say that Malaysian food sucks and if I found out that you've been to a crappy place I'll lead you to "true Malaysian food".

So how is this a fallacy in this case?

I stand corrected.

Please send me a PM of any song you like that I most probably never heard of! I am looking for people to chat about writing and producing music | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noD-bsOcxuU |
huameng
Profile Blog Joined April 2007
United States1133 Posts
October 27 2011 06:53 GMT
#2
The fallacy is that there is no value in saying "All american food, except the stuff that is bad, is good." Well of course all of the "true American food" is good if you just define "true American food" to be American food that isn't bad. If you keep saying "oh you didn't like that food? It must not have been true American food, try this instead" you have a fallacy; if you say "American food is good, but McDonalds and other fast food places are garbage so they don't count." you do not have a fallacy, as long as you don't go back and keep updating what you meant by "American food" to exclude more and more.
skating
Chariot
Profile Joined November 2007
United States36 Posts
October 27 2011 07:01 GMT
#3
Essentially, the fallacy would actually look like this:

"All american food is good"

"I don't like McDonalds"

"Oh well, that's not *true* american food"

-----

Your phrasing is actually different:

"All american food sucks because McDonalds sucks"

Obviously, in this case it is a fallacy to generalize from some american food to all of it.
Dhalphir
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
Australia1305 Posts
October 27 2011 07:05 GMT
#4
The fallacy is basically when you redefine a statement you made in order to cover up something you said that was flat out wrong.

For example, saying "All American food is good" is clearly making a bold claim - that is then trounced by saying "what about mcdonalds?" the fallacy is then when you cover up the fact that you made an unsupported, incorrect claim by redefining what you meant by "American".

For example, if you said "A lot of American food is good" and someone said "Mcdonalds sucks", there would be no fallacy if you said "Well McDonalds isn't even true American food", because you left room for there to be exclusions in your original statement.
Supporting TypeII Gaming - www.typeii.net - TypeReaL, TypePhoeNix, TypeSuN, TypeDBS!!
ZaplinG
Profile Blog Joined February 2005
United States3818 Posts
October 27 2011 07:27 GMT
#5
idk wtf you guys are talking about... I like mcdonalds and their 1$ double cheeseburgers/frosties
Don't believe the florist when he tells you that the roses are free
ComaDose
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
Canada10357 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-10-27 07:28:53
October 27 2011 07:28 GMT
#6
McDonalds is pretty tasty tho. No fallacy.
EDIT: Ninja joke sniped by one minute
BW pros training sc2 is like kiss making a dub step album.
blah_blah
Profile Joined April 2011
346 Posts
October 27 2011 07:35 GMT
#7
In technical language, say that you have a set of objects S, some of which have property P, and some of which do not have property P.

The 'no true scotsman fallacy' is conflating the obviously true statement 'Every object in S which has property P has property P' with the false statement 'Every object in S has property P'.
JieXian
Profile Blog Joined August 2008
Malaysia4677 Posts
October 28 2011 12:21 GMT
#8
Ok thanks for the explaination. I forgot about the blog until today..

Your phrasing is actually different:

"All american food sucks because McDonalds sucks"

Obviously, in this case it is a fallacy to generalize from some american food to all of it.


My examples were generalisation problems right?
Please send me a PM of any song you like that I most probably never heard of! I am looking for people to chat about writing and producing music | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noD-bsOcxuU |
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Wardi Open
11:00
#44
WardiTV1254
OGKoka 952
Harstem440
Rex149
CranKy Ducklings142
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
OGKoka 986
Harstem 430
Lowko214
Rex 132
Vindicta 5
StarCraft: Brood War
Rush 4944
JulyZerg 3835
zelot 3166
Sea 2377
firebathero 1887
EffOrt 967
Larva 689
Zeus 579
Stork 472
PianO 320
[ Show more ]
Mind 170
Pusan 151
ToSsGirL 117
Sharp 61
Barracks 57
soO 54
Movie 49
Shinee 47
sSak 39
sorry 29
Shine 26
Terrorterran 21
Bale 11
SilentControl 10
IntoTheRainbow 9
Stormgate
NightEnD10
Dota 2
qojqva3801
XcaliburYe509
syndereN447
League of Legends
Dendi1269
Counter-Strike
flusha620
oskar162
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King119
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor192
Other Games
singsing2135
B2W.Neo1328
hiko986
Fuzer 439
crisheroes360
Happy286
SortOf164
ArmadaUGS85
QueenE34
Liquid`VortiX31
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick5091
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• StrangeGG 41
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• C_a_k_e 2060
League of Legends
• Nemesis5203
Upcoming Events
RotterdaM Event
2h 35m
Replay Cast
20h 35m
WardiTV European League
1d 2h
ShoWTimE vs sebesdes
Percival vs NightPhoenix
Shameless vs Nicoract
Krystianer vs Scarlett
ByuN vs uThermal
Harstem vs HeRoMaRinE
PiGosaur Monday
1d 10h
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
The PondCast
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
Epic.LAN
3 days
CranKy Ducklings
4 days
[ Show More ]
Epic.LAN
4 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
5 days
Bonyth vs Sziky
Dewalt vs Hawk
Hawk vs QiaoGege
Sziky vs Dewalt
Mihu vs Bonyth
Zhanhun vs QiaoGege
QiaoGege vs Fengzi
Sparkling Tuna Cup
5 days
Online Event
6 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
6 days
Bonyth vs Zhanhun
Dewalt vs Mihu
Hawk vs Sziky
Sziky vs QiaoGege
Mihu vs Hawk
Zhanhun vs Dewalt
Fengzi vs Bonyth
Liquipedia Results

Completed

2025 ACS Season 2: Qualifier
RSL Revival: Season 1
Murky Cup #2

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
BSL20 Non-Korean Championship
Championship of Russia 2025
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters

Upcoming

CSL Xiamen Invitational
CSL Xiamen Invitational: ShowMatche
2025 ACS Season 2
CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
BSL Season 21
K-Championship
RSL Revival: Season 2
SEL Season 2 Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
FEL Cracov 2025
Esports World Cup 2025
Underdog Cup #2
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.