• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 21:09
CEST 03:09
KST 10:09
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)11Code S RO4 & Finals Preview: herO, Rogue, Classic, GuMiho0TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy5Code S RO8 Preview: herO, Zoun, Bunny, Classic7Code S RO8 Preview: Rogue, GuMiho, Solar, Maru3
Community News
Weekly Cups (June 9-15): herO doubles on GSL week2Firefly suspended by EWC, replaced by Lancer12Classic & herO RO8 Interviews: "I think it’s time to teach [Rogue] a lesson."2Rogue & GuMiho RO8 interviews: "Lifting that trophy would be a testament to all I’ve had to overcome over the years and how far I’ve come on this journey.8Code S RO8 Results + RO4 Bracket (2025 Season 2)14
StarCraft 2
General
The SCII GOAT: A statistical Evaluation Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025) TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy Weekly Cups (June 9-15): herO doubles on GSL week The Memories We Share - Facing the Final(?) GSL
Tourneys
RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament $5,100+ SEL Season 2 Championship (SC: Evo) SOOPer7s Showmatches 2025 SOOP Starcraft Global #22
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response Simple Questions Simple Answers [G] Darkgrid Layout
Custom Maps
[UMS] Zillion Zerglings
External Content
Mutation # 478 Instant Karma Mutation # 477 Slow and Steady Mutation # 476 Charnel House Mutation # 475 Hard Target
Brood War
General
FlaSh Witnesses SCV Pull Off the Impossible vs Shu StarCraft & BroodWar Campaign Speedrun Quest ASL20 Preliminary Maps BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion
Tourneys
[BSL 2v2] ProLeague Season 3 - Friday 21:00 CET Small VOD Thread 2.0 [BSL20] GosuLeague RO16 - Tue & Wed 20:00+CET [BSL20] ProLeague Bracket Stage - WB Finals & LBR3
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do. [G] How to get started on ladder as a new Z player
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Path of Exile Beyond All Reason What do you want from future RTS games?
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine UK Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Echoes of Revolution and Separation
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
[Manga] One Piece Korean Music Discussion
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NHL Playoffs 2024 Formula 1 Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
A Better Routine For Progame…
TrAiDoS
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Heero Yuy & the Tax…
KrillinFromwales
I was completely wrong ab…
jameswatts
Need Your Help/Advice
Glider
Trip to the Zoo
micronesia
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 32519 users

No true Scotsman Fallacy

Blogs > JieXian
Post a Reply
JieXian
Profile Blog Joined August 2008
Malaysia4677 Posts
October 27 2011 06:43 GMT
#1
I have a question after seeing this being used around here.

If I say American music sucks, you may tell me to stay away from Justin Bieber and Lil Wayne and listen to "true American music"

If I say American food sucks, you may ask me to look further than McDonalds or the crap cooked in a particular crappy restaurant I went to and instead eat "true American food".

If I say American movies suck, you may call me an idiot for only watching Transformers and Twilight and dig deeper for "true American movies"

Nothing against America, I know I'll do the same if you say that Malaysian food sucks and if I found out that you've been to a crappy place I'll lead you to "true Malaysian food".

So how is this a fallacy in this case?

I stand corrected.

Please send me a PM of any song you like that I most probably never heard of! I am looking for people to chat about writing and producing music | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noD-bsOcxuU |
huameng
Profile Blog Joined April 2007
United States1133 Posts
October 27 2011 06:53 GMT
#2
The fallacy is that there is no value in saying "All american food, except the stuff that is bad, is good." Well of course all of the "true American food" is good if you just define "true American food" to be American food that isn't bad. If you keep saying "oh you didn't like that food? It must not have been true American food, try this instead" you have a fallacy; if you say "American food is good, but McDonalds and other fast food places are garbage so they don't count." you do not have a fallacy, as long as you don't go back and keep updating what you meant by "American food" to exclude more and more.
skating
Chariot
Profile Joined November 2007
United States36 Posts
October 27 2011 07:01 GMT
#3
Essentially, the fallacy would actually look like this:

"All american food is good"

"I don't like McDonalds"

"Oh well, that's not *true* american food"

-----

Your phrasing is actually different:

"All american food sucks because McDonalds sucks"

Obviously, in this case it is a fallacy to generalize from some american food to all of it.
Dhalphir
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
Australia1305 Posts
October 27 2011 07:05 GMT
#4
The fallacy is basically when you redefine a statement you made in order to cover up something you said that was flat out wrong.

For example, saying "All American food is good" is clearly making a bold claim - that is then trounced by saying "what about mcdonalds?" the fallacy is then when you cover up the fact that you made an unsupported, incorrect claim by redefining what you meant by "American".

For example, if you said "A lot of American food is good" and someone said "Mcdonalds sucks", there would be no fallacy if you said "Well McDonalds isn't even true American food", because you left room for there to be exclusions in your original statement.
Supporting TypeII Gaming - www.typeii.net - TypeReaL, TypePhoeNix, TypeSuN, TypeDBS!!
ZaplinG
Profile Blog Joined February 2005
United States3818 Posts
October 27 2011 07:27 GMT
#5
idk wtf you guys are talking about... I like mcdonalds and their 1$ double cheeseburgers/frosties
Don't believe the florist when he tells you that the roses are free
ComaDose
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
Canada10357 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-10-27 07:28:53
October 27 2011 07:28 GMT
#6
McDonalds is pretty tasty tho. No fallacy.
EDIT: Ninja joke sniped by one minute
BW pros training sc2 is like kiss making a dub step album.
blah_blah
Profile Joined April 2011
346 Posts
October 27 2011 07:35 GMT
#7
In technical language, say that you have a set of objects S, some of which have property P, and some of which do not have property P.

The 'no true scotsman fallacy' is conflating the obviously true statement 'Every object in S which has property P has property P' with the false statement 'Every object in S has property P'.
JieXian
Profile Blog Joined August 2008
Malaysia4677 Posts
October 28 2011 12:21 GMT
#8
Ok thanks for the explaination. I forgot about the blog until today..

Your phrasing is actually different:

"All american food sucks because McDonalds sucks"

Obviously, in this case it is a fallacy to generalize from some american food to all of it.


My examples were generalisation problems right?
Please send me a PM of any song you like that I most probably never heard of! I am looking for people to chat about writing and producing music | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noD-bsOcxuU |
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
The PiG Daily
00:20
Best Games of SC
Maru vs Solar
Reynor vs Clem
Serral vs Zoun
PiGStarcraft422
LiquipediaDiscussion
OSC
19:00
Mid Season Playoffs
Babymarine vs MojaLIVE!
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft422
Nina 144
NeuroSwarm 141
Livibee 119
RuFF_SC2 92
Vindicta 27
StarCraft: Brood War
NaDa 82
Icarus 1
League of Legends
JimRising 138
Counter-Strike
PGG 64
Other Games
summit1g10487
C9.Mang0838
ViBE233
Mew2King119
Trikslyr86
PPMD42
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1046
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 68
• HeavenSC 19
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki60
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Doublelift6830
Upcoming Events
Replay Cast
51m
SOOP
7h 51m
Cure vs Zoun
SC Evo League
10h 51m
Road to EWC
12h 51m
SOOP Global
13h 51m
FuturE vs MaNa
Harstem vs Cham
BSL: ProLeague
16h 51m
Sziky vs JDConan
Cross vs MadiNho
Hawk vs Bonyth
Circuito Brasileiro de…
18h 51m
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 8h
Road to EWC
1d 12h
BSL: ProLeague
1d 16h
UltrA vs TBD
Dewalt vs TBD
[ Show More ]
Replay Cast
3 days
Replay Cast
4 days
The PondCast
5 days
Replay Cast
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Acropolis #3 - GSC
2025 GSL S2
Heroes 10 EU

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
BSL Season 20
Acropolis #3
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 2
NPSL S3
Rose Open S1
CSL 17: 2025 SUMMER
Copa Latinoamericana 4
NPSL Lushan
Championship of Russia 2025
RSL Revival: Season 1
Murky Cup #2
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters
CCT Season 2 Global Finals
IEM Melbourne 2025
YaLLa Compass Qatar 2025
PGL Bucharest 2025

Upcoming

CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
K-Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
SEL Season 2 Championship
Esports World Cup 2025
HSC XXVII
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.